Independent Insurance Agency, Cicero, IN
Serving Indianapolis and All of Indiana with health, home, auto, and business insurance.
Health Insurance
From group benefits for your business to individual and family plans, we find coverage that actually fits.
Group Health Insurance
Comprehensive group health plans built around your team's needs.
Individual & Family Health Insurance
ACA marketplace and private plans for individuals and families.
Dental and Vision Insurance
Individual dental and vision plans to cover the gaps.
Medicare
We compare Medicare plans across multiple carriers to find the right fit for your doctors and budget.
Medicare Supplement Insurance
Fill the gaps in Original Medicare with the right supplement plan.
Medicare Advantage Plans
All-in-one Medicare coverage that bundles medical, drug, and extra benefits.
Medicare Part D
Standalone prescription drug coverage matched to the medications you take.
Home & Auto
We shop multiple carriers to find the right home and auto coverage for your family and your budget.
Commercial Insurance for Indiana Businesses
We work with businesses of all sizes to find the right commercial insurance coverage, including general liability, commercial property, workers’ comp, and professional liability.
Whether you are a sole proprietor or a growing company with employees, we take time to understand your operation before we ever recommend a policy.
An Independent Insurance Agency Working for You
When you work with an independent insurance agency, you get options, not a pitch. We shop the market across multiple carriers to find coverage that fits.
Since 2012, Cicero Insurance Agency has helped individuals, families, and business owners across Cicero, Noblesville, Sheridan, Tipton, Elwood, and surrounding Indiana communities find coverage that actually makes sense for their situation. We are not tied to any single carrier, which means we compare plans honestly and recommend only what fits your needs, your doctors, and your budget. Nothing more, nothing less.
Coverage for Every Stage of Life
Our clients come to us at every stage of life, and no two situations look the same. We take time to understand yours before we ever make a recommendation.
Some are business owners exploring group health benefits for the first time. Others are turning 65 and trying to make sense of Medicare. Some just want better rates on their home and auto without losing coverage they depend on. Whatever brings you here, Cicero Insurance Agency has the experience and the independence to find what actually fits. Most of our clients never need to look anywhere else.
Why Choose Us?
Cicero Insurance Agency brings together experience, independence, and genuine care for every client we serve. We are here to make insurance simpler, not harder.
60 Years of Combined Experience
We Work With All Major Insurance Carriers
Locally, Family, and Woman-Owned
Small Town Roots, Statewide Reach
Established in 2012
Free Consultations
We Work With All Major Carriers!
What Clients Like You Say
Real people across Cicero, Noblesville, Sheridan, Tipton, Elwood, and surrounding IN, trust us with their coverage. Here is what some of them have to say.
“I have sought to renew my insurance and went to Cicero Insurance agent. Terri Milbrook took us through different options. She knew what we need and helped us to find the most reasonable plan without forfeiting any of our coverage. This was not the first time we went to Cicero and Terri Millbrook. Several years she has assisted us in finding the best for us.”
“We have been clients of Cicero Insurance about 15 years…when we were getting into Medicare. Terri Milbank, our agent, has been very thorough in helping us and seeing that we have gotten the best for the cost. Trust your senior Medicare needs to them. You won’t be disappointed.”
“Jay D and his team have always been a pleasure to work with. If you’re a small business looking for insurance options you will get a lot more than just a quote. You will get a better understanding of how to keep your business and employees safe.”
Ready to Find the Right Coverage?
Cicero Insurance Agency is here to help you compare options, ask questions, and get covered with confidence. Contact us today for your free consultation.